Ohio
Casualty Company
Customer Service Number: 1-800-888-7764
Report a Claim: 1-800-FON-OHIO
Billing Inquiry: 1-800-THE-OHIO Option 1
Progressive
Policy Service: 1-800-888-7764
Billing Inquiry: 1-800-999-8781
Claims Service: 1-800-766-4737
Travelers
Claims Service: 1-800-252-4633
Donegal
Companies
Claims Service: 1-800-877-9006
Billing Inquiry: 1-800-877-0600
Utica
First Insurance Company
Billing Inquiry: 1-800-456-4556 Option 8
Customer Service: 1-800-456-4556